Defender Source Forum banner

Banging Noise

1 reading
4.8K views 22 replies 8 participants last post by  kiefffff  
#1 ·
I have searched and found some great info, but wanted to post also for some feedback. Just recently replaced the stock driveshafts with custom tom woods double cardan shafts and just replaced motor mounts and tc mounts. Used the qt service mounts for the motor, stock rubber mounts for tc.

Prior to these updates, had a metal vibration type sound appear when motor/exhaust/etc. reached normal temp. Happened during deceleration at stops. Thought maybe a cat was going bad. Since these updates, have a banging clanging noise when decelerating and accelerating. Kinda sounds like the driveshaft is banging the crossmember or something. Inspected, didn't notice anything of the sort.

This is really weird. Wondering if it could be since the driveline angle has been kinda bad, with the stock shafts and 3"lift, that by allieviating this with the double cardan shaft it released some sort of failure in the tc or transmission? Bearing?

Anyone experience a similar issue with brand new double cardan shafts with brand new spicer u joints? Is there a "break in" period that may cause this banging noise?

Any advice would be appreiciated.
 
#2 ·
There are a lot of unrelated things that can cause those noises. For instance, I had a very worn-out steering joint that allowed a lot of the longer steering rods too much clearance, resulting in a bonking sound when accellerating, shifting and stopping quickly.

Other folks have had similar sounds coming from worn out suspension bushings.

The stock style cats have a tendency to break apart internally sometimes, which causes rattling noises at times.

I'd start by just getting under there when the truck is cool, grabbing various things and giving them a good shake.

-Hans
 
#5 ·
I plan to get under it tomorrow and shake some stuff around. I'll check the bushings too. The rear links are new, so hope those aren't bad already. Could be the front radius arms. Those are still stock. Its just kinds weird that it was not there prior to mounts and shafts, then bang!

It sounds like someone taking a hammer and hitting the frame. Would this start in the drivetrain after double cardan shafts allievate angle issues?
 
#8 ·
Visually checked it and grabbed it to see if it was loose. Seemed okay. Is there another way to check it? Clue me in.
The clanging noise seems to occur when rpms are around 2000 and decelerating. Its like a bonk, bonk, bonk, as the driveshaft comes to a stop and is rotating. May be out of balance or input/output angle issue?
 
#9 ·
Might also be a bad U-joint, they can be deceptively hard to diagnose. To really check them, you need to chock the rear wheels and put everything in neutral. Otherwise, because of the location of the parking brake, the tension on the driveshaft can make them SEEM solid even if they are about to collapse.

-Hans
 
#12 ·
kiefffff said:
Some friends of mine think it is coming from the transfer case. Anything in there that could be causing this noise?
Hand brake shoe?
 
#14 ·
What are the options for the transfer case? Places to buy or rebuild? What have all of you done that had tc issues?
Got under truck again with it running and can hear a grinding type noise coming from the case. It may "explode" any day! My guess is that previous owner mechanic rounded off the fill plug on the transfer case. Last time oil was replaced, had to fill thru sensor. Done by dealer. My guess is that the gears are worn out due to abuse and since the drivetrain geometry has been corrected with new motor mounts and trans mounts, and new shafts, new diffs, etc., the bearing is bouncing around in the case and gear wear is more evident. Hope this diagnostic is correct! Sounds good anyway. Thanks for all of your suggestions.
 
#16 ·
Well, I also suggest checking if it's the "Clunk of doom" before ordering a transfer case. It may actually be the transmission output shaft wearing out, which extends into the transfer case. This would mean a new transmission, but the transfer case would be fine still.

Thankfully, that can be checked without much hassle. You just need to remove the PTO cover from the transfer case and the input gear will slide out for inspection. There are a few good websites that covert the problem, I'll see if I can dig them up later.

-Hans
 
#17 ·
Thank you Hans. Will need to check that too. Can you explain how the dealer refilled the transfer case through the sensor? I would need to do the same since the fill plug will not come out. If it is the transmission output shaft, how long will it last before it goes? I may have multiple issues going on, which may result in both the transmission and transfer case. That would really suck.
 
#18 ·
Refilled through the sensor? Maybe he removed the speedometer cable and filled through there? He would have to use one of those syphon tools, I forget the correct name.... it looks like giant syringe but with a flexible tube instead of a needle... I got mine at Napa.

Anyways, the output shaft could last months if you baby it (and if it IS actually a problem), or it could go anytime. Most people that had it go bad say it just goes out on them suddenly with no real warning, just CLUNK and the truck don't move anymore. But because the output shaft from the tranny goes really far into the transfer case, the problem will sound like it's the transfer going, even though the part that is failing is part of the transmission.

-Hans
 
#19 ·
Can the shaft be replaced with the transfer case removed, or do you have to drop the transmission too? All I see are $$$$.
Another question, if one or the other or both need replacement, would you deal directly with Ashcroft in England or would you work through Atantic British or Rover North type outfit here in the states? Any cost savings? Thanks again for the feedback.
 
#21 ·
The shaft was an issue on the earlier 90's with the LT-77's as well, and not all of them got the retrofit parts. I've also heard that in some cases the LT-77's were replaced with R-380's under warranty.

Unfortunately, replacing the shaft means tearing down the transmission. But it is possible that it's already been repaired/upgraded, which is why you need to check before spending money on replacing the whole transmission.

You also mentioned that you need to replace the transfer case, what's wrong with it? They are usually one of the more durable parts of the truck.
 
#23 ·
Just want to say thanks to all for the help. Under advice from Steve and Drew at Rovertym, I re-checked the rear pinion angle again. Took all the spacers out of the Rovertym rear links. So far, the banging, clanging noise I was hearing has gone away. The other noises, playing card in bike spokes, etc, are still there. My guess is tranny output shaft or TC input. At this time, plan to ride it till something breaks or gets to the point of having to replace. Hope it doesn't happen on my way out to Utah next year!